Choosing between mulch and stone is one of the most common decisions homeowners face when updating their landscape beds. Both options have clear benefits and a few drawbacks, depending on your goals, maintenance style, and the look you want for your outdoor space. Understanding the differences helps you make a choice that fits your yard, your budget, and your long-term plans.
Mulch: Natural, Plant-Friendly, and Great for Moisture Control
Mulch is a favorite in Wisconsin landscapes because it supports plant health while giving beds a clean, polished look.
Benefits of Mulch
- Improves soil health as it breaks down.
- Retains moisture, reducing watering needs.
- Keeps roots cool during hot summers.
- Suppresses weeds when installed at the proper depth.
- Adds organic matter to the soil over time.
- Soft, natural appearance that complements most homes.
Considerations
- Needs refreshing every 1-2 years.
- Can fade or decompose.
- May attract some insects, though rarely a problem when installed correctly.
Mulch is ideal for plant-heavy beds, new installations, and clients who want a softer, natural look.
Stone: Clean, Durable, and Low-Maintenance
Stone is a long-lasting option that works especially well in modern designs, around foundations, or in areas where plants are minimal.
Benefits of Stone
- Extremely durable and does not break down.
- Low maintenance once installed.
- Great for drainage in problem areas.
- Does not fade as quickly as mulch.
- Resistant to wind and erosion.
Considerations
- Higher upfront cost.
- Can allow moisture to escape soil and cause root systems to dry out.
- Weeds can still appear, so weed barrier and maintenance are important.
- Harder to remove if you change your mind later.
Stone is ideal for low-maintenance landscapes, foundation beds, hot, sunny areas, and clients who prefer a clean, modern look.
Mulch vs. Stone: What We Recommend at M.Y. Landscaping
Because we work in Wisconsin's climate and soil conditions every day, we have learned what performs best in different situations.
Mulch is usually best when:
- You have lots of shrubs, perennials, or new plantings.
- You want healthier soil over time.
- You prefer a natural, earthy look.
- You're refreshing existing beds.
Stone is usually best when:
- You want the lowest maintenance option.
- You have drainage issues around the foundation.
- You're designing a modern or structured landscape.
- You have minimal plantings or mostly evergreens.
How We Install Mulch and Stone the Right Way
No matter which option you choose, proper installation makes all the difference.
For Mulch Beds
- We remove weeds at the root.
- Apply weed preventer.
- Shape and edge the bed.
- Install mulch at the correct depth, typically 2-3 inches.
For Stone Beds
- We remove existing weeds and debris.
- Install a high-quality weed barrier.
- Add edging to contain the stone.
- Spread stone evenly for a clean, finished look.
Both options can look incredible. It just depends on your goals.
So, Which One Should You Choose?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer. Mulch and stone both have their place in a well-designed landscape. The right choice depends on your maintenance style, your plant types, your long-term plans, your budget, and the look you want. If you are unsure, we can walk your yard with you and help you choose the option that fits your space and your vision.